Harassment Prevention When Federal Guidance Is Rescinded: Build Your Own Standard

Key takeaways
- New enforcement focus: The EEOC has released a National Enforcement Plan that replaces the 2023 Strategic Enforcement Plan (phillipslytle.com).
- Shift in litigation: The EEOC intends to move away from using disparate impact claims and will stop pursuing current lawsuits relying on those claims (phillipslytle.com).
- Prioritization of intent: Federal enforcement will prioritize disparate treatment cases involving intentional discrimination (phillipslytle.com).
- Program scrutiny: The DOJ is seeking information regarding workplace programs under the False Claims Act (kmklaw.com).
On June 4, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) released a National Enforcement Plan (NEP) that rescinds the Strategic Enforcement Plan approved in 2023 (phillipslytle.com). This new plan is currently in effect and will remain in place through 2029 (phillipslytle.com).
What the new enforcement landscape looks like
The shift in federal oversight changes how HR teams must approach compliance. The EEOC's stated goal is to shift to a conservative view of civil rights (kmklaw.com). Under this new framework, the agency intends to move away from using disparate impact claims and will stop pursuing current lawsuits relying on those claims (phillipslytle.com). Instead, the EEOC will prioritize disparate treatment cases involving intentional discrimination (phillipslytle.com).
This change in priority moves the regulatory focus from the outcomes of neutral policies to the intent behind specific actions. In the past, disparate impact claims allowed regulators to challenge policies that appeared neutral but had a disproportionately negative effect on certain groups. Now, the focus is on whether an employer acted with the intent to discriminate (phillipslytle.com).
The implications for internal auditing are significant. While the agency moves away from disparate impact, it is simultaneously increasing scrutiny on specific types of programming. Chair Lucas stated that the EEOC will focus enforcement efforts on race-restricted programs, sex-restricted programs, or other actions involving overt distinctions between people based on race (kmklaw.com).
The EEOC's focus is shifting toward intentionality. This means the "how" of your policy matters as much as the "what" when it comes to avoiding disparate treatment claims (phillipslytle.com).
Why It Matters
Comparing the regulatory shifts
To understand the current environment, we can compare the previous enforcement focus with the new National Enforcement Plan. This comparison highlights the shift from systemic outcome monitoring to intentionality-based enforcement.
| Feature | Previous Focus (Pre-2026) | New NEP Focus (2026-2029) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Legal Theory | Disparate Impact (systemic outcomes) (phillipslytle.com) | Disparate Treatment (intentionality) (phillipslytle.com) |
| Primary Target | Neutral policies with unequal effects (phillipslytle.com) | Overt distinctions based on race or sex (kmklaw.com) |
| Program Scrutiny | Broad systemic review (phillipslytle.com) | Race-restricted or sex-restricted programs (kmklaw.com) |
The mechanism of "Intent" vs. "Impact"
When we talk about the "people mechanism" behind these legal shifts, we are talking about how employees perceive fairness and how investigators prove intent. If an HR team implements a training program that is only available to one specific demographic, a regulator may view this as an overt distinction (kmklaw.com).
One reading is that this shift provides more clarity for employers. If the EEOC is not pursuing disparate impact, companies may feel less pressure to constantly re-calculate the statistical outcomes of every minor policy change. However, the counter-reading is that the risk of "intentionality" claims remains high. If a program functions like DEI, regardless of whether it is called DEI, belonging, or 'EO', it remains subject to scrutiny (kmklaw.com).
Analysis: Consider two scenarios regarding recruitment. In Scenario A, a company uses a standardized test that results in fewer minority hires, but the test is strictly job-related. Under the old guidance, this might have triggered a disparate impact claim. In Scenario B, a company creates a mentorship program specifically for women to increase representation. Under the new guidance, Chair Lucas cautioned that this could be viewed as a sex-restricted program (kmklaw.com).
What the data does not say
As HR leaders, we must be careful about the data available to us. While the EEOC has outlined its enforcement priorities, the data does not currently show the volume of new False Claims Act demands related to workplace programs (kmklaw.com). While the DOJ is seeking information about workplace programs under the False Claims Act, we do not yet have a confirmed number of active investigations or the specific criteria they will use to define a "violation" in a private corporate setting (kmklaw.com).
Also, while Chair Lucas encouraged white male employees who believe they have experienced discrimination based on race or sex to contact the EEOC (kmklaw.com), there is no current data showing the volume or the specific nature of these incoming claims. We cannot assume that an increase in "encouragement" by the Chair will lead to a linear increase in filings, nor can we assume the current level of litigation will decrease. We only know the stated intent of the regulators.
Building an internal standard for harassment
With federal guidance shifting, organizations cannot rely solely on a "check the box" approach to federal compliance. If the EEOC is moving toward a focus on intentionality and overt distinctions, your internal standards must be grounded in objective, non-discriminatory business needs. This is not about abandoning culture, but about ensuring that the mechanisms used to support employees do not inadvertently create the "overt distinctions" the EEOC is targeting (kmklaw.com).
The risk is no longer just "Does this policy have a bad outcome?" but "Can this policy be interpreted as an intentional distinction based on a protected characteristic?" (kmklaw.com). To manage this, HR must move from a compliance-based model to a standard-based model. A standard is a set of internal rules that apply to everyone, regardless of their race, sex, or other protected characteristics, and is tied to specific, documented business requirements.
A policy that is applied differently to different groups to achieve a specific demographic outcome may be viewed as a sex-restricted or race-restricted program (kmklaw.com).
Watch For
What HR can do on Monday morning
To prepare for the 2026-2029 enforcement cycle, HR teams should audit their current programs against the new definitions of "overt distinctions" and "intentionality." We should focus on the mechanics of how programs are offered, who is invited to participate, and how those decisions are documented.
- Audit program eligibility: Review all mentorship, leadership development, and recruitment programs. Ensure that eligibility is based on job role, tenure, or performance metrics rather than demographic characteristics (kmklaw.com).
- Review documentation of intent: Examine the "business case" documents for any program that has a specific demographic component. If a program is designed to support a specific group, ensure the documentation focuses on a business necessity rather than a demographic goal (kmklaw.com).
- Standardize training delivery: Ensure that all mandatory training (harassment, compliance, or culture) is offered to all employees simultaneously or via a non-discriminatory rotation to avoid claims of sex-restricted or race-restricted access (kmklaw.com).
- Review internal terminology: Audit internal communications to ensure that programs are described by their functional purpose (e.g., "Leadership Development") rather than by demographic labels that could be interpreted as overt distinctions (kmklaw.com).
The regulatory environment has moved from measuring the "footprint" of a policy to measuring the "intent" of the actor. Organizations that build their own standards based on objective, documented business needs will be better positioned to navigate this shift through 2029 (phillipslytle.com).