Podcasts
Human Resources

Open Enrolment 2027: Communicating Cost Increases Without Losing Goodwill

Fizza Fatima NaqviNovember 2, 20267 min read
Open Enrolment 2027: Communicating Cost Increases Without Losing Goodwill

Key takeaways

Marsh analysts project that employers' health benefits costs could rise 8.2% in 2027 (fiercehealthcare.com). This projection is based on preliminary results from the 2026 National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans, which utilized data from over 1,800 employers as of August 10, 2026 (fiercehealthcare.com).

The gap between projections and employer expectations

There is a notable variance in how different organizations and analysts project the upcoming year. While Marsh analysts suggest an 8.2% rise, other data points suggest a higher trajectory for those who do not adjust their current plans. For instance, WTW anticipated an 11.1% increase in healthcare costs in 2027 if no plan design changes are made (planadviser.com). Similarly, some employers estimate that current plan costs would increase by 11% in 2027 if no mitigation actions are taken (fiercehealthcare.com).

This discrepancy is not necessarily an error in data, but rather a reflection of different starting points. Analysts often look at the broad market trend, whereas individual employers look at their specific plan designs. When an organization looks at its own "status quo" cost, they are often looking at a higher number because they are including the compounding effect of current trends without the intervention of new cost-containment strategies (fiercehealthcare.com).

The practical implication is that HR leaders cannot rely on a single "market average" to set their 2027 strategy. If an employer follows a general market projection but ignores the specific drivers within their own population, they may find themselves underfunded by the time Open Enrollment arrives. This is particularly critical because, as Ellen Kelsay stated in August 2026, most employers have already locked in their budgets and strategies for the next year (planadviser.com).

Few organizations can absorb health cost increases that outpace inflation without making difficult financial decisions (fiercehealthcare.com).

Why It Matters

Understanding the mechanics of cost drivers

To communicate cost increases effectively, HR leaders must understand the specific mechanisms driving the numbers. A significant driver identified by Marsh actuaries is the rising utilization of GLP-1 medications, which is estimated to account for a full percentage point of the overall cost growth for 2027 (fiercehealthcare.com). Also, the IFEBP survey, which included 112 U.S. employers, found that 67% of respondents identified GLP-1 drugs as the medication costing them the most (planadviser.com).

When employees see premiums rise, they often attribute the change to general inflation or "corporate mismanagement." They may not realize that a specific category of medication, one that may or may not be used by their specific demographic, is shifting the entire actuarial balance for the group. This creates a disconnect between the employee's personal experience and the employer's financial reality.

Analysis: The GLP-1 effect is a matter of "aggregate impact" versus "individual impact." An employee who does not use these medications may feel the premium increase is an unfair "tax" to cover someone else's prescription. Conversely, an employee who does use these medications may see a restriction in coverage or a higher copay as a personal loss. This is a classic tension in group insurance: the collective cost is driven by a subset of the population, but the cost is distributed across the whole.

Comparing the data landscape

Because different surveys use different methodologies, HR leaders must look at the range of data rather than a single figure. The following table summarizes the various projections and survey scopes available as of late 2026.

Source Metric/Focus Projected 2027 Increase Survey Scope/Date
Marsh Employer health benefit costs 8.2% (fiercehealthcare.com) 1,800+ employers (Aug 2026) (fiercehealthcare.com)
Aon Average healthcare costs per employee 9.5% spike (fiercehealthcare.com) N/A
WTW Costs if no plan design changes made 11.1% (thefiscaltimes.com) 471 employers (June-Aug 2026) (planadviser.com)
Employers (General) Current plan cost increase (no mitigation) 11% (fiercehealthcare.com) N/A

What the data does not say is how these increases will impact employee retention or engagement. While we can see the financial trajectory, we cannot use these surveys to predict how an employee will react to a 5% increase in their monthly premium. The data shows the "what," but the "how" of employee sentiment remains an unmeasured variable in these actuarial reports.

The risk of the "Mitigation Gap"

There is a tension between the need to cut costs and the need to maintain a competitive benefits package. Marsh survey respondents indicate that 59% of employers plan to make cost-cutting changes to health benefits next year (fiercehealthcare.com). This suggests that more than half of the market is moving toward plan design changes, such as higher deductibles, narrower networks, or more stringent prior authorization requirements.

Analysis: A "Mitigation Gap" occurs when an employer attempts to absorb costs through the bottom line (profit) rather than through plan design, but the costs eventually exceed the margin. As Simon Camaj of Marsh noted, few organizations can absorb health cost increases that outpace inflation without making difficult financial decisions (fiercehealthcare.com). If an HR team waits too long to implement mitigation strategies, they may be forced into "emergency" plan changes during Open Enrollment, which is far more damaging to goodwill than planned, transparent adjustments.

The counter-reading to the "cost-cutting" trend is the "value-add" strategy. Some organizations may choose not to cut benefits but instead to change the *type* of benefits offered, for example, shifting funds from traditional coverage to mental health support or wellness programs. However, if the total cost to the employee increases regardless of the benefit type, the communication challenge remains the same.

The tension lies in the distinction between "cost-shifting" (moving costs to the employee) and "cost-containment" (reducing the total spend through better management).

Watch For

Communicating the "Why" without losing the "Who"

When Open Enrollment arrives, the communication strategy often fails because it focuses on the "What" (the new premium) instead of the "Why" (the market drivers). If an employer says, "Premiums are going up because costs are higher," it feels like a circular argument to an employee. If an employer says, "Premiums are increasing by 8% due to a 11% rise in pharmaceutical utilization and general medical inflation," they are providing a mechanism.

The goal is to move from a defensive posture to an educational one. This does not mean the employer is responsible for global medical inflation, but it does mean the employer is the messenger of a reality that affects the employee's take-home pay. We must be careful not to blame specific groups of employees (such as those using GLP-1s) for the cost increases, as this creates a culture of resentment. Instead, the focus should remain on the systemic drivers of the healthcare economy.

Analysis: There is a psychological difference between a "price increase" and a "resource reallocation." A price increase feels like a loss. A resource reallocation, where the company explains that to keep the premium from rising 11%, they have adjusted the plan design to keep it at a 5% increase, is seen as a proactive management of a shared resource. The latter is much harder to achieve, but it is the only way to preserve goodwill during a period of high inflation.

What HR can do on Monday morning

Preparation for 2027 Open Enrollment should not begin in October. Because most budgets are already locked in, the window for strategic maneuvering is narrow. HR teams should move from reactive budgeting to proactive communication planning immediately.

  1. Audit the "No-Action" Scenario: Ask your brokers to run a "status quo" projection for your specific population. Compare this to the 11.1% WTW benchmark to see where your organization sits (thefiscaltimes.com).
  2. Segment the Driver Data: Determine if your specific plan's cost growth is being driven by pharmacy (like GLP-1s) or medical services. This allows for more specific, rather than generic, communication (planadviser.com).
  3. Develop a "Tiered Communication" Plan: Create three versions of your benefit announcement: one for the general population, one for high-utilizers (focusing on continuity of care), and one for low-utilizers (focusing on the collective stability of the plan).
  4. Review the "Mitigation" Timeline: If you are part of the 59% of employers planning cost-cutting changes, ensure those changes are finalized before the budget lock-in period ends (fiercehealthcare.com).

As we move into the final months of 2026, the data suggests that the 2027 Open Enrollment period will be defined by a struggle between rising medical costs and the necessity of organizational fiscal health. The leaders who succeed will be those who treat benefits communication not as a notification of a price hike, but as a transparent report on the economic forces shaping the workforce.

Written byFizza Fatima Naqvi

Fizza helps organizations strengthen the people side of performance, from recruitment and onboarding to performance management, training, and employee relations. An HR professional with an MBA in Human Resource Management and a BBA with Honours, she has hands-on experience as an HR Generalist, supporting recruitment, onboarding, performance appraisal, HR policy implementation, and employee training workshops. Her grounding in research methodology and statistical analysis informs how she approaches human resource questions.