Private Credit or Bank Debt: A Borrower's Term-Sheet Comparison

Key takeaways
- Default rates: Companies with EBITDA of US$100 million or more show a covenant default rate of 1.4% (blackrock.com).
- Structural trends: Approximately 90% of private credit loans are now classified as covenant-lite (gfmag.com).
- Liquidity risks: Investors requested US$20.8 billion in redemptions in the first quarter, occasionally exceeding the 5% cap set by major firms (gfmag.com).
- Risk allocation: Private credit typically offers higher pricing in exchange for greater structural flexibility and speed.
In the current credit environment, companies with EBITDA of US$100 million or more exhibit a covenant default rate of 1.4% (blackrock.com). This figure serves as a baseline for understanding how large-scale borrowers interact with their debt obligations. For a CFO, the choice between a traditional bank loan and a private credit facility is not merely a question of interest rate, but a decision regarding the specific mechanics of the term sheet and the subsequent impact on operational freedom.
The pricing mechanism: Spread vs. Speed
The most immediate differentiator is the cost of capital. Bank debt is generally priced lower because banks operate under different regulatory capital requirements and have access to cheaper, stable deposit bases. Private credit funds, conversely, are often seeking higher absolute returns to satisfy their own investor mandates. This higher pricing is the premium a borrower pays for certainty of execution and speed. When a company needs capital for a rapid acquisition, the "certainty of funds" in a private credit deal often outweighs the basis point savings of a bank loan.
The credit view focuses on the "all-in" cost. A credit committee does not just look at the margin (the spread over a base rate), but also at the arrangement fees, commitment fees, and any PIK (payment-in-kind) components. A PIK feature allows a borrower to pay interest by adding it to the principal rather than paying cash. While this preserves cash flow in the short term, it creates a compounding debt burden that an underwriter will scrutinize heavily during the next renewal or refinancing cycle.
The premium paid for private credit is often a payment for the removal of "certainty risk" regarding funding timelines and closing conditions.
Why It Matters
Covenants: The disappearance of the early warning system
Traditional bank debt relies heavily on maintenance covenants. These are periodic tests (usually quarterly) where the borrower must prove they are meeting specific financial ratios, such as a maximum leverage ratio or a minimum interest coverage ratio. If a borrower fails a test, they are in technical default, even if they have not missed a payment. This gives the bank a seat at the table to renegotiate terms before a total liquidity crisis occurs.
The landscape has shifted toward "covenant-lite" structures. Around 90% of private credit loans are now covenant-lite (gfmag.com). In these agreements, many of the maintenance covenants are removed, replaced by "incurrence covenants" that only trigger if the borrower takes a specific action, such as issuing more debt or making a large acquisition. This provides significant operational flexibility for the borrower. However, the practical implication is that the lender loses the ability to intervene early. Without maintenance covenants, the first sign of trouble for a lender might be a missed payment, rather than a breach of a financial ratio.
The Credit Committee's Five-Point Test
When evaluating a loan, a credit committee typically applies five primary lenses to the proposal:
- Cash Flow: Can the EBITDA comfortably cover interest and principal?
- Collateral: What is the liquidation value of the assets if the borrower fails?
- Covenants: What are the triggers for default, and how much "headroom" exists?
- Structure: Is the debt senior or subordinated? Are there any "leakage" provisions?
- Sponsor/Management: Does the equity holder have the "skin in the game" to support the company through a downturn?
Flexibility and the "Default" definition
The definition of a default differs significantly between these two pools. In a bank-led environment, a breach of a leverage ratio is a "technical default." This allows the bank to waive the breach for a fee or renegotiate the interest rate. In a private credit environment, particularly with covenant-lite structures, the boundary between a "warning sign" and a "default" is much sharper (gfmag.com).
For a borrower, the lack of maintenance covenants means they can operate with more aggressive capital allocation strategies without asking for permission. However, this flexibility is a double-edged sword. If the company's leverage increases due to poor EBITDA performance, the borrower cannot "fix" the ratio through a covenant waiver; they simply find themselves in a position where they may eventually fail to meet an incurrence test or a payment obligation. The credit view is that covenant-lite structures shift the risk of "bad decisions" from the lender to the borrower by delaying the point of intervention.
Liquidity and redemption risks in private markets
While borrowers focus on their own liquidity, they must also consider the liquidity of their lender. In the first quarter, investors requested US$20.8 billion in redemptions from private credit funds, sometimes exceeding the 5% cap set by firms like Apollo Global Management, Ares Management, Blackstone, Blue Owl Capital, and KKR (gfmag.com). This indicates that while the credit market is growing, it is also subject to investor outflows that can create pressure on the fund's ability to hold long-term, illiquid assets.
If a private credit fund faces significant redemptions, it may become less willing to extend "rescue financing" or participate in secondary market transactions. A borrower should assess whether their lender has a stable capital base or if they are part of a fund facing high redemption volatility. A bank, being a depository institution, generally has a more stable, albeit more regulated, funding profile.
Illustrative example
The following numbers are hypothetical and round. A mid-market manufacturing company requires US$500 million in senior secured debt. Under a Bank Debt scenario, the company faces an interest rate of SOFR plus 300 basis points, but must maintain a Debt/EBITDA ratio below 4.0x, tested quarterly. Under a Private Credit scenario, the rate is SOFR plus 550 basis points, but the loan is covenant-lite, meaning no quarterly ratio tests are required unless the company takes on additional debt. The analysis shows that while the private credit option is more expensive on an annual basis, it provides the company with more "breathing room" to navigate a potential 15% drop in EBITDA without triggering a technical default.
Comparing the Terms: A Summary
| Feature | Bank Debt (Traditional) | Private Credit (Covenant-Lite) |
|---|---|---|
| Covenant Type | Maintenance (Quarterly tests) | Incurrence (Event-driven) |
| Speed/Certainty | Moderate (Rigid process) | High (Customizable) |
| Default Warning | Early (Ratio breach) | Late (Payment or action breach) |
Strategic Analysis: When to choose which?
The decision should be driven by the company's specific lifecycle stage and its projected volatility. There are two primary scenarios to consider:
Scenario A: The Stable Compounder. A company with predictable, high-margin cash flows and a management team focused on incremental, organic growth. For this borrower, bank debt is often the superior choice. The lower cost of capital provides a permanent saving, and the maintenance covenants act as a useful discipline that prevents management from over-leveraging the balance sheet. The "credit view" here is that the borrower is trading unnecessary expense for the benefit of institutional oversight.
Scenario B: The Opportunistic Aggressor. A company in a period of rapid M&A or a highly cyclical industry where EBITDA can fluctuate wildly. For this borrower, private credit is often the pragmatic choice. The higher cost of capital is a "flexibility premium." The ability to operate without the threat of a quarterly technical default, even if EBITDA dips temporarily, allows the company to focus on its turnaround or integration strategy rather than managing lender relationships. The "credit view" here is that the borrower is paying for the ability to manage their own risk profile without external interference.
The choice between bank and private credit is a choice between the cost of capital and the cost of compliance.
Watch For
Next Steps for Treasury and Finance Functions
Borrowers should not view this as a binary choice but as a spectrum of capital structuring. To prepare for upcoming refinancing cycles, consider the following actions:
- Stress-test the "Covenant-Lite" Fallacy: Do not assume covenant-lite means "no risk." Model your cash flows against an incurrence-based model to see how much leverage you can actually sustain before a major event triggers a default.
- Review Lender Liquidity: For private credit deals, ask your lenders about their recent redemption trends and capital stability.
- Analyze the "Spread Gap": Calculate the exact dollar cost of the spread difference between a bank and a private fund. Determine if the "flexibility premium" is actually worth the specific operational freedom you expect to gain.