The Manager Squeeze: Why Manager Engagement Fell Fastest

Key takeaways
- Managerial engagement decline: Manager engagement has fallen from 27% to 22% (benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com).
- Mental health disparity: Two in five senior managers reported receiving a new mental health diagnosis in the past 12 months, compared to 13% for non-managers (journalofaccountancy.com).
- Workplace anxiety: 72% of workers reported feeling pressured to work through mental health struggles, up from 62% in 2025 (journalofaccountancy.com).
- AI-driven uncertainty: 74% of senior managers expect AI to lead to layoffs in their companies within the next three years (journalofaccountancy.com).
Gallup's State of the Global Workplace: 2026 Report, released on a Wednesday, indicates that management has become a central organizational issue rather than a technology one, according to Gallup CEO Jon Clifton (benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com).
The math of the manager squeeze
The data shows a significant divergence in how different levels of the workforce experience the current work environment. While engagement in best-practice organizations remains high at 79% for managers (benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com), the broader trend shows manager engagement has dropped from 27% to 22% (benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com). This decline is not just a statistical shift; it represents a widening gap in how leadership roles are being experienced compared to individual contributors.
To understand this, we must look at the specific pressures placed on those in middle and senior management. The data suggests that the burden of organizational stability is falling disproportionately on leaders. For example, 72% of workers reported feeling pressured to work through mental health struggles, which is an increase from 62% in 2025 (journalofaccountancy.com). When managers are part of that 72%, they face a dual pressure: they must manage the productivity of their teams while simultaneously managing their own health under the same systemic pressures (journalofaccountancy.com).
The mechanism here is a feedback loop of stress. If 51% of employees say they have cried due to work stress in the month leading up to the survey (journalofaccountancy.com), the manager is often the person tasked with absorbing that emotional volatility. They are the buffer between high-level strategic demands and the immediate, human needs of a distressed workforce. This buffering role is exhausting, and the data suggests it is taking a measurable toll on the mental health of those in leadership roles.
A disparity in mental health outcomes
The most striking evidence of this squeeze is found in the mental health data for senior managers. According to the journal of accountancy, two in five senior managers said they received a new mental health diagnosis in the past 12 months (journalofaccountancy.com). This rate is more than three times the 13% rate reported by non-managers (journalofaccountancy.com).
This is not a correlation we should take lightly. It suggests that the specific nature of management work, the accountability for others, the responsibility for business outcomes, and the constant mediation of conflict, creates a unique risk profile. We must distinguish between the general stress of work and the specific clinical outcomes reported by these cohorts. While the data shows a higher rate of diagnosis among managers, it does not explain whether this is due to higher stress levels, higher rates of self-reporting, or increased access to healthcare within management tiers.
When we compare these two groups, the gap is clear:
| Cohort | New Mental Health Diagnosis (Last 12 Months) |
|---|---|
| Senior Managers | 40% (Two in five) (journalofaccountancy.com) |
| Non-managers | 13% (journalofaccountancy.com) |
This disparity suggests that the "manager squeeze" is not just about workload, but about the psychological cost of leadership in a volatile environment.
The gap between manager engagement and the mental health of senior leadership suggests that the people responsible for driving engagement are themselves facing significant clinical challenges.
Watch For
The shadow of automation and political anxiety
Two additional factors are compounding the pressure on managers: the fear of technological displacement and the impact of the external political environment. 74% of senior managers expect AI to lead to layoffs in their company within three years (journalofaccountancy.com). This creates a paradox of leadership. Managers are expected to drive the adoption of AI to increase efficiency, yet they are simultaneously navigating the personal and professional anxiety caused by that very technology (journalofaccountancy.com).
Also, the external environment is bleeding into the workplace. 70% of respondents believe the current U.S. political environment has made it harder to maintain positive mental health at work (journalofaccountancy.com). While 71% of respondents believe that politically driven anxiety could be reduced through workplace mental health support, the reality on the ground is more complicated (journalofaccountancy.com).
There is a notable disconnect in how companies approach mental health. While 33% of employees strongly agree that their employer values their mental health, this is a decrease from 41% in 2025 (journalofaccountancy.com). This decline in perceived support is critical because 50% of employees say they do not use employer-provided mental health days because they fear judgment (journalofaccountancy.com). For a manager, the fear of judgment is often doubled: they fear being judged by their superiors for a lack of resilience, and they fear being judged by their subordinates if they appear vulnerable (journalofaccountancy.com).
Analysis: The counter-reading of the data
An analytical view requires us to look at the alternative explanations for these numbers. One reading is that the rise in mental health diagnoses among managers is a sign of a failing leadership pipeline. If the most critical layer of the organization is experiencing a mental health crisis at three times the rate of the rest of the staff, the ability to execute strategy is fundamentally compromised.
However, a counter-reading is that this data might reflect a "reporting effect" rather than a "sickness effect." It is possible that senior managers have better access to healthcare and more resources to seek formal diagnoses than entry-level employees. It is also possible that the 13% rate for non-managers is an undercount due to the stigma mentioned earlier, where 50% of people avoid using mental health benefits due to fear of judgment (journalofaccountancy.com).
If burnout is affecting productivity to some degree for the vast majority of the workforce, the manager's role becomes one of crisis management rather than leadership. In this scenario, engagement does not fall because managers are lazy or unmotivated, but because they are operating in a state of permanent cognitive and emotional exhaustion (journalofaccountancy.com).
The cost of the engagement gap
When manager engagement falls, the impact is felt throughout the entire organizational structure. Managers are the primary drivers of employee experience. If managers are disengaged, they are less likely to provide the support that 71% of people believe could reduce anxiety (journalofaccountancy.com).
We see a direct link between the perceived value of mental health and the actual use of support. If only 33% of employees feel their employer values their mental health, the culture is likely one of "performance at any cost" (journalofaccountancy.com). This culture directly feeds the 72% of workers who feel they must work through mental health struggles (journalofaccountancy.com). For the organization, this creates a cycle of diminishing returns: productivity is hampered by burnout, and the cost of replacing the managers who leave due to the "squeeze" becomes a significant financial liability.
The risk is not just a loss of morale; it is a loss of operational capacity. If 74% of senior managers are anticipating layoffs due to AI, the psychological contract between the employee and the employer is being rewritten in real-time (journalofaccountancy.com). Managers are tasked with managing this transition, which requires high levels of empathy and stability, the very things they are currently lacking.
What HR can do on Monday morning
We cannot solve systemic political anxiety or the global shift toward AI overnight. However, HR teams can address the immediate mechanics of the manager squeeze by moving from vague "wellness" initiatives to specific, structural supports. We must stop treating manager burnout as a personal failing and start treating it as an organizational risk.
To move the needle on manager engagement and mental health, HR should implement the following:
- Audit the "Shadow Workload": Review the non-operational tasks currently assigned to managers. Specifically, measure the time spent on conflict mediation and mental health support versus actual strategic or operational work.
- Normalize Mental Health Usage: To address the 50% of employees who fear judgment for using mental health days, leadership must explicitly communicate the use of these days in a way that is not tied to "recovery" but to "maintenance."
- Segment Manager Support: Do not use the same mental health resources for all levels. Senior managers require different support mechanisms, such as peer-to-peer executive coaching, than individual contributors, given the specific diagnosis rates seen in the data (journalofaccountancy.com).
- Clarify AI Transitions: To mitigate the anxiety of the 74% of managers expecting AI-related layoffs, HR should provide clear, documented timelines regarding how AI will be integrated into specific roles (journalofaccountancy.com).
The goal is to stabilize the middle. If we cannot support the people who support the rest of the organization, the engagement numbers will continue to slide, regardless of how many wellness apps the company purchases.