Podcasts
Human Resources

Quits Are Rising Again: What the September JOLTS Data Means for Retention Strategy

Fizza Fatima NaqviNovember 4, 20267 min read
Quits Are Rising Again: What the September JOLTS Data Means for Retention Strategy

Key takeaways

  • Rising quits: The quits rate increased to 2.1 percent in September from 1.9 percent in August (kpmg.com).
  • Labor tightness: The ratio of job openings to unemployed job seekers edged higher to 1.1 in September (kpmg.com).
  • Sectoral skew: Most resignations occurred in the accommodation and food services and construction industries (coloradobiz.com).
  • Wage gap: ADP Pay Insights estimated a 1.8 percentage point wage premium for job changers in September (kpmg.com).

According to the September JOLTS data, the number of resignations increased by 321,000 to 3.365 million, reaching the highest level since March 2025 (coloradobiz.com).

What the data says about the September shift

The labor market is showing signs of increased movement. The quits rate rose to 2.1 percent in September from 1.9 percent in August (kpmg.com). This increase in voluntary departures is happening alongside a rise in job openings, which stood at 7.5 million at the end of September (kpmg.com). For context, there were 7.1 million job openings at the end of August (kpmg.com).

The relationship between available roles and the available workforce has tightened. The ratio of job openings to unemployed job seekers was 1.0 in August (kpmg.com), but it rose to 1.1 in September (kpmg.com). This means there are more vacancies available for every person looking for work than there were the previous month (kpmg.com). When this ratio rises, it often indicates a more competitive environment for employers, as the supply of available labor does not keep pace with the volume of open roles (coloradobiz.com).

We also see a divergence in how different sectors are behaving. While the overall quits rate is up, the movement is not uniform across the economy. The data indicates that most resignations occurred in the accommodation and food services and construction industries (coloradobiz.com). In the accommodation and food services sector specifically, hiring increased by 158,000 in September, while quits increased by 197,000 (kpmg.com). This suggests a "leaky bucket" scenario where the volume of people leaving the sector is outpacing the volume of new people entering it (coloradobiz.com).

Conversely, other sectors show different pressures. Job openings in healthcare and social assistance remain elevated at 1.5 million (kpmg.com). This indicates that while some sectors are struggling with high turnover, others are dealing with a persistent shortage of available workers to fill existing roles (kpmg.com).

The gap between those who stay and those who move is a primary driver of turnover. When the cost of moving is low and the wage gain is high, the decision to quit becomes a rational economic choice for the employee.

Why It Matters

The mechanism of the "Quit Premium"

To understand why employees are leaving, we must look at the financial incentive to change employers. Data from ADP Pay Insights estimated a 1.8 percentage point wage premium for job changers in September (kpmg.com). This means that, on average, people who moved to new roles saw a higher pay increase than those who stayed in their current positions (kpmg.com).

This wage gap creates a specific behavior in the labor market. When an employee perceives that their current employer is providing raises that lag behind the market rate, the "opportunity cost" of staying becomes too high. This is not necessarily a reflection of dissatisfaction with culture or management, but rather a mathematical response to the wage gap (kpmg.com).

The hiring rate also rose to 3.4 percent in September from 3.3 percent in August (kpmg.com). This indicates that companies are actively trying to capture this moving talent, even as they lose their own. When the hiring rate and the quits rate both rise, it suggests a highly fluid market where talent is being redistributed rather than simply disappearing (kpmg.com).

What the data does not say

As HR leaders, we must be careful not to over-interpret these numbers. While the JOLTS data tells us how many people quit, it does not tell us why they quit. The data measures movement, but it does not measure motivation. We cannot distinguish between a "resignation for growth" (moving to a better role) and a "resignation due to friction" (leaving because of poor management or burnout) based on these figures alone (coloradobiz.com).

Also, these are macro-level statistics. They aggregate millions of data points into a single percentage. We must also recognize that the JOLTS data is a snapshot of a specific moment in time; it is a lagging indicator of the labor market's health (coloradobiz.com).

It is also important to note the distinction between layoffs and quits. The layoff rate is 1.1 percent, and layoffs and discharges decreased by 127,000 to 1.641 million, reaching the lowest level since March 2025 (coloradobiz.com). This tells us that the increase in quits is not being driven by fear of unemployment or mass restructuring, but by active choice (coloradobiz.com). People are leaving because they have options, not because they are being pushed out by economic contraction (coloradobiz.com).

Analysis: Comparing market scenarios

To better understand where we are, we can compare the current September environment to the August environment and the broader economic context.

Metric August 2026 September 2026
Quits Rate 1.9% (kpmg.com) 2.1% (coloradobiz.com)
Hiring Rate 3.3% (kpmg.com) 3.4% (kpmg.com)
Job Openings to Unemployed Ratio 1.0 (kpmg.com) 1.1 (kpmg.com)
Unemployment Rate 4.1% (kpmg.com) 4.2% (kpmg.com)

Scenario A: The "Tight Market" (Current Status)

In this scenario, the ratio of openings to seekers is above 1.0, and the quits rate is rising (kpmg.com). This suggests a market where employees feel empowered to seek higher wages elsewhere. For HR, this is a "retention-heavy" environment. The focus must be on protecting the existing talent pool because the cost of replacing them is rising due to the wage premium (kpmg.com).

Scenario B: The "Stagnant Market" (Hypothetical)

Illustrative example

The following numbers are hypothetical. In this scenario, the primary HR challenge shifts from retention to engagement and productivity, as the threat of turnover diminishes.

Scenario C: The "Recessionary Market" (Hypothetical)

Illustrative example

The following numbers are hypothetical. The power dynamic would shift heavily toward employers, and the wage premium for job changers would likely evaporate.

When quits rise while layoffs fall, the market is signaling confidence. Employees are not running away from their current companies out of fear; they are running toward new opportunities because they believe the market is stable.

Watch For

What HR can do on Monday morning

We cannot control the macro economy or the ADP wage premium, but we can control our internal response to these trends. If your industry is seeing a rise in quits, such as the accommodation or construction sectors (coloradobiz.com), you should move from reactive hiring to proactive retention. We should not wait for exit interviews to understand why people are leaving; we should use the data to predict who might leave next.

To move from theory to practice, HR teams should implement the following measures:

  1. Audit the "Stay Premium": Compare your internal annual merit increase rates against the 1.8 percentage point wage premium reported by ADP (kpmg.com). If your internal increases are significantly lower than the market's movement, you are effectively subsidizing your competitors' recruitment efforts.
  2. Segment Turnover Data: Do not look at the company-wide quits rate in isolation. Segment your turnover data by department and tenure. Specifically, look for "high-performer churn" within the first 12 to 24 months. This identifies if the issue is onboarding or mid-term career progression.
  3. Monitor the Openings-to-Hires Gap: Track the time it takes to fill a role versus the rate at which people in that role are leaving. If your hiring rate is 3.4% but your turnover in a specific department is 5%, you are in a state of permanent recruitment, which is a high-cost, low-stability cycle (kpmg.com).
  4. Review the "Flight Risk" Indicators: Instead of waiting for resignations, track "passive indicators" such as a sudden decrease in internal training participation or a drop in engagement scores in specific departments.

The September data suggests that the labor market is not cooling, but rather shifting into a more active phase of movement (coloradobiz.com). The rise in the quits rate to 2.1 percent is a signal that the "cost of staying" is increasing for your employees (coloradobiz.com). For executives, the priority should be ensuring that the internal cost of staying is competitive enough to offset the external temptation of the job-change premium.

Written byFizza Fatima Naqvi

Fizza helps organizations strengthen the people side of performance, from recruitment and onboarding to performance management, training, and employee relations. An HR professional with an MBA in Human Resource Management and a BBA with Honours, she has hands-on experience as an HR Generalist, supporting recruitment, onboarding, performance appraisal, HR policy implementation, and employee training workshops. Her grounding in research methodology and statistical analysis informs how she approaches human resource questions.